Subjective measurements of thermal comfort (TC) and temperature sensation (TS) are used to assess thermal environments, but tend to have large inter-individual variability, making them unsuitable for group descriptions of subjective feelings. As a consequence a more objective measure of thermal perception would be useful. Nielsen et al (2001), found a strong relationship between oesophageal temperature (Toes) and the α/β index of electroencephalographic (EEG) activity during cycling in the heat. When a similar protocol was followed, a relationship between the subjective measurement of rating of perceived exertion (RPE) and Toes was established (Nybo & Nielsen, 2001). As TC and TS are correlated with both Toes and RPE (via body temperature), the possibility exists that α/β index reflects TC and TS rather than Toes. This hypothesis was tested in the present experiment. Following ethical approval and informed consent, the EEG activity of fifteen cortical regions (F4,F3,F7,F8,C4,C3,Cz,P4,P3,O2,O1,T4,T3) were recorded (Trackit T24, Lifelines, UK) in five physically active males during three, 20 minute periods of cycling at work intensities that elicited 50, 75, and 85% of maximum heart rate, followed by 40 minutes of rest. Each trial was conducted in 35oC air, 50% RH. Fast Fourier transformation was used to obtain power spectrum areas in α (8-13 Hz) and β (13-13 Hz). Percentage change of α and α/β activity from rest were used as indicators of arousal level (Nielsen et al, 2001). TC, TS, RPE and rectal temperature (TRE) were also measured alongside the EEG recordings. Pearson correlation coefficients were used to describe any relationships. Paired-sample t-tests were used to analyse comparisons. During exercise TRE increased by 1.02 ± 0.3°C to 38.51± 0.52°C. Increases in TRE and RPE were significantly correlated (r = 0.91; P<0.001). Increases in TRE were associated with an elevated α activity in the frontal regions F3 (r = 0.567; P<0.05) and F7 (r = 0.66; P<0.05). Elevations in α activity and RPE were also correlated in these regions (F3: r = 0.66; P < 0.05; F7: r = 0.56; P<0.05). No relationships were established between α and α/β activity and TS or TC. With the omission of RPE, by comparing α and α/β activity during and post-exercise rest, at the same TRE, α/β activity was only significantly elevated at the cortical region F4 (9.00 ± 22.37% vs. 33.24 ± 10.66%; P<0.05). However, a 1°C increase in TRE caused an increase (P<0.05) in α/β activity in all the frontal regions (F3: 4.31 ± 32.52% vs. 58.99 ± 50.00; F4: 11.50 ± 12.68% vs. 48.74 ± 17.12; F7: -7.59 ± 10.87% vs. 55.04 ± 30.16%; F8: 1.78 ± 17.22% vs. 45.77 ± 24.12%). It is concluded that changes in brain activity are not a valid objective measurement of TC and TS. Therefore, the experimental hypothesis is rejected. Brain activity also appears to be associated with alterations in TRE rather than RPE.
King's College London (2009) Proc Physiol Soc 14, PC16
Poster Communications: Can brain activity be used as an objective measure of thermal perception?
S. L. Davey1, M. Tipton1, J. Holman2
1. Sport & Exercise, University of Portsmouth, Portsmouth, United Kingdom. 2. Dept. of Electroencephalography, St. Mary's Hospital, Portsmouth, United Kingdom.
View other abstracts by:
Where applicable, experiments conform with Society ethical requirements.