Ethnic differences in heat adaptation and autonomic tone during intensive exercise in elite athletes

37th Congress of IUPS (Birmingham, UK) (2013) Proc 37th IUPS, PCA275

Poster Communications: Ethnic differences in heat adaptation and autonomic tone during intensive exercise in elite athletes

J. Dalzell2, A. Datta1

1. Medicine, Hull York Medical School, York, United Kingdom. 2. formerly Portsmouth FC, Portsmouth, United Kingdom.

View other abstracts by:


INTRODUCTION: Athletic performance may be compromised in extreme heat; this was relevant for the Athens and Beijing Olympics and may be for the 2014 (Brazil) and 2022 (Qatar) FIFA World cups; under those conditions prior determination of required fluid intake is vital for athlete safety. Thompson (1954) described lower sweating rates in Bantus compared with Caucasians. AIMS 1.To determine the English Football Premiership ethnic mix. 2.To establish fluid intake, sweat production and sweat evaporation during exercise in extreme heat and their ethnic differences. 3.To establish cardiorespiratory and other physiological factors contributing to any putative ethnic differences METHODS: Using Scout 7 software, the English Football Premiership was analysed for ethnic background in 2012. 34% players were of African origin(AO) and 66% of European origin(EO). On two successive years, studies were performed in Dubai after four days acclimation, during 80 minutes training at 40 ± 2°C ambient temperature; 25 ± 8% relative humidity on 29 professional Premiership footballers from a single team with Ethics clearance. 15 were AO and14 EO. Players could drink ad libitum. RESULTS: There was no difference between AO and EO in height, weight, body surface area, skin fold thickness, resting or average heart rate during exercise, QT interval, cardiac chamber dimensions, left ventricular ejection fraction or maximum VO2. During exercise, fluid intake in AO ranged from 1.1- 3.0l (1.6 + 0.63l, median + SD) and in EO ranged from 0.5-2.4 l (1.35 + 0.50; p=0.40; unpaired t-test). Sweat production in AO ranged from 1.8 – 3.9 l (2.3 + 0.54 l) higher than 1.3 – 2.7 l in EO (2.00 + 0.43 l; p = 0.03; Figs. 1&2). Mean ± SD of Peak Heart Rate (Polar Electro) during training in the heat was 186 ± 7 bpm ( range 170-197 bpm) in AO footballers, significantly higher than EO players (178 ± 7 bpm, range 165-188 bpm ; p=0.007). Heart rate variability (HRV; Akselrod, 1981) was calculated from a five minute collection of resting ECG using bespoke frequency domain analysis software using American Heart Association guidelines (Omega Wave; Oregon USA). (Mean +SD) LF/HF ratio, an index of sympatho-vagal tone balance was 1.07 + 0.48 in AO and significantly higher in EO 2.0+ 1.27 (p= 0.03). CONCLUSIONS 1. A large proportion of the English Premiership footballers are AO 2. Sweat production during exercise in extreme heat may be up to 3.25 L/hr, and fluid intake 2L/hr. This can lead to significant dehydration of up to 2.4% naked body mass. 3. There is greater sweat production in AO players, despite a similar fluid intake to EO players; this may confer a performance advantage to exercise in the heat. 4. Increased sweat production in AO players appears to be associated with an increased sympathetic tone, which has also been related to an increased risk of cardiac events (Tsuji et al, 1996)



Where applicable, experiments conform with Society ethical requirements.

Site search

Filter

Content Type